Christmas Desserts

Sleigh the holidays with Jonny C’s N.Y. Deli! We are NOW ACCEPTING ORDERS for Christmas Desserts!

Call (716) 688-8400 today to place your order or go online to (We kindly ask 24 hours notice.)

(5 Assorted Kinds: Frosted Sugar Cookies, M&M’s, Peanut Butter Blossoms, Raspberry Thumbprints, and Red Velvet Crinkles.)
1 Dozen Box – $15
Small Tray – $30 (1/2 dozen of each, 30 total)
Large tray – $55 (1 dozen of each, 60 total)

(Assorted Mini Brownies: Plain, Peanut Butter, Frosted)
24 pieces – $30

(Build Your Own Tray: Plain, Chocolate Chip, and Chocolate Covered)
Large Cannolis – $3.50 Each
Mini Cannolis – $1.50 Each

$18 Each: Oreo, Pumpkin, and Peanut Butter Pretzel
$22 Each: Banana Cream, Chocolate Cream, Coconut Cream, Dutch Apple, and Pecan

Holiday Gift Cards

Take advantage of our Jonny C’s N.Y. Deli Holiday Gift Card Specials!

Buy a $50 card, get a $10 bonus card!
Buy a $100 card, get a $25 bonus card!

Offer good through 12/31/23!

Jonny C’s is Hiring!

Apply Now

Help us spread the word that we are CURRENTLY HIRING:

  • Cashiers
  • Sandwich Makers
  • Short Order Cooks
  • Dishwashers

Job highlights:

  • $15-$18/hour
  • Medical, Dental, Vision
  • On the Job Training
  • Employee Meals, Discounts, Tips

Welcome to Jonny C’s!

Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers is owned by Jon Cohen, a native of the New York City area who has owned and operated numerous delis and restaurants. Having been involved in the foodservice industry since the age of sixteen, he has incorporated many ideas and concepts into his Buffalo restaurants. Jonny C’s NY Deli in East Amherst opened in November of 2006.

Jonny C’s is located at 9350 Transit Road in East Amherst, New York right at the corner of Casey Road. It is a self-service deli featuring an eat-in dining room that is decorated with lots of New York City Nostalgia, with takeout being an available option as well. A wide variety of specialty meats and cold cuts are sold by the pound in addition to our extensive menu of delicious over-stuffed sandwiches, hot entrees, salads, side, and soups.

December 4th – December 10th Weekly Specials

Sub of the Week:
Da Bomb

Chopped Steak with Cherry Pepper Mayo, Sautéed Onions, Sautéed Spinach, and Melted Fontina Cheese all served on a Toasted Sub Roll.

Sweet of the Week:
Orange Chocolate Cheesecake

Oreo Crust, Orange Chocolate Cheesecake filling, topped with Lindt Intense Orange and Almond Chocolate Ganache with creamy chocolate whipped cream.

Sweet of the Week:
Gingerbread Whoopie Pie

Fluffy Vanilla frosting sandwiched between two ginger molasses cookies.

Counter Item of the Month:
Christmas Cookies

This year’s varieties include Frosted Sugar Cookies, M&M’s, Peanut Butter Blossoms, Raspberry Thumbprints, and Red Velvet Crinkles.

Soups of the Week:

Monday – Buffalo Chicken Finger

Tuesday – Roasted Red Pepper Bisque

Wednesday – Stuffed Hot Pepper and Sausage

Thursday – Cream of Mushroom

Friday – Seafood Bisque

Jonny C’s: A Buffalo Catering Company
You Can Count On

Hosting an event? Give yourself peace of mind and worry about one less thing when you take advantage of Jonny C’s premier catering services.

Jonny C’s offers catering services on and off the premises.