Thanksgiving Pies & Trays

Call TODAY to place your order at 716-688-8400.

$20 Per Pie:

  • Pumpkin
  • Oreo Fudge

$24 Per Pie:

  • Dutch Apple
  • Pecan
  • Banana Cream
  • Chocolate Cream
  • Peanut Butter Pretzel

$30 Per Brownie Tray (24 Mini Pieces):

  • Assorted Brownie Tray (Plain, Peanut Butter, & Chocolate Frosted)

Jonny C’s is Hiring!

Help us spread the word that we are CURRENTLY HIRING:

  • Cashiers
  • Sandwich Makers
  • Short Order Cooks
  • Dishwashers

Job highlights:

  • $15-$18/hour
  • Medical, Dental, Vision
  • On the Job Training
  • Employee Meals, Discounts, Tips

Welcome to Jonny C’s!

Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers is owned by Jon Cohen, a native of the New York City area who has owned and operated numerous delis and restaurants. Having been involved in the foodservice industry since the age of sixteen, he has incorporated many ideas and concepts into his Buffalo restaurants. Jonny C’s NY Deli in East Amherst opened in November of 2006.

Jonny C’s is located at 9350 Transit Road in East Amherst, New York right at the corner of Casey Road. It is a self-service deli featuring an eat-in dining room that is decorated with lots of New York City Nostalgia, with takeout being an available option as well. A wide variety of specialty meats and cold cuts are sold by the pound in addition to our extensive menu of delicious over-stuffed sandwiches, hot entrees, salads, side, and soups.

November 17th – 22nd Weekly Specials


Melt of the Week:
Super Mario

Fried Pepperoni with Fried Ravioli, Sautéed Banana Peppers, Marinara, Garlic Spread, and Melted Mozzarella all Served on your choice of Grilled Bread.

Sweet of the Week:
Caramel Apple Cheesecake

A graham cracker crust filled with sliced apples and caramel, creamy brown sugar cinnamon cheesecake, and topped with cinnamon sugar apple slices, and a little more caramel.

Sweet of the Week:
Molasses Cream Pies

Cinnamon Vanilla buttercream sandwiched between two molasses spice cookies.

Counter Item of the Week:
Candy Bar Cookies

This candy bar cookie features Reese, Snickers, Kit Kat, M&Ms, and Butterfinger.

Soups of the Week:

Monday – Cheesy Ham

Tuesday – Beef Barley  

Wednesday – Split Pea

Thursday – Cream of Green Bean

Friday – Seafood Bisque

Jonny C’s: A Buffalo Catering Company
You Can Count On


Hosting an event? Give yourself peace of mind and worry about one less thing when you take advantage of Jonny C’s premier catering services.

Jonny C’s offers catering services on and off the premises.